Sunday, June 7, 2009

Terry Pratchett

Last night I finished The Amazing Maurice and his Educated Rodents by Terry Pratchett. I've seen lots of Pratchett books around (he's wildly popular--especially in Britain), but I'd never picked one up until Kami's list revitalized my need to stay up until all hours reading. It was . . . different. I came away from it thinking--holy cow that was creative and unexpected and weird. I mean, did any of you expect to read a book about a talking cat who cajoles a bunch of talking rats to con whole towns into thinking there's a rat infestation and then hiring a rat piper (also in the cat's employ) to get rid of them? No, I hadn't expected to ever read a book like that either. On top of that, it was a philosophy book exploring the creation of religion and morality. Bet that caught you unawares. Me too. And while the writing was good, the plot incredibly clever, the philosophy interesting, I still went away thinking, "That was kind of a boy book." I'm so hard to please. Read it though--it was definitely worth reading. Whether or not I think it should be on a list for a nine-year-old, I'm not really sure. I'm leaning towards no--unless the nine year old had been me, or a reader like me. Judgement calls on age-appropriateness are just so tricky.

2 comments:

Sara and Justin said...

So nothing about the commentary on the book you just read.... but I think you should tell the story of how Miriam took Emily and Nora on an adventure at Beckie's birthday party last night. Merribeth just told me the story. Scary at first but a good ending that you can eventually laugh about.

Polly said...

I have read a couple of Terry Pratchets including this one- and well they are creative, and reasonable well written, and have interesting messages- all things I like in a book- but something is just missing and they fail to grab me the way a really special book does. Just writing this is making me want to reread the Abhorsen. But I don't like Garth Nix's other series.